Next IOSH Working Safely in Events: 26 November!

CASE STUDY

Soho Theatre: A Preventable Fall with Life-Changing Consequences

You're not signed in yet

Sign up for a free account to read this case study and download the full PDF.

What happened?

On 9 June 2012, 38-year-old stage manager Rachael Presdee was working at Soho Theatre in London on Headlong Theatre’s production of Boys. She had not previously worked at the venue. While preparing for a performance, Presdee needed to locate the stage lighting controls.

The auditorium was dark, and she went up a spiral staircase looking for a member of theatre staff who could help her. At the top of the stairs she encountered an ordinary-looking, unmarked door. There were no warning signs indicating that there was a significant drop behind it.
Presdee opened the door and encountered a black curtain. Curtains of this type are commonplace backstage, and she believed she was entering another room or backstage area. Instead, she stepped through the curtain and into open space. The doorway was approximately three metres above the stage. Presdee fell onto the stage below and suffered catastrophic spinal injuries.

The “Juliet door”

The doorway was sometimes referred to as a “Juliet door” because an elevated doorway of this type could be used for scenes such as the balcony scene in Romeo and Juliet. The problem was that when it was not being used for a performance, the doorway still presented a potentially fatal fall-from-height hazard. At the time of Presdee’s accident, the door was:

• unlocked;
• unmarked;
• without appropriate warning signage;
• not protected by a suitable barrier preventing somebody walking through it; and
• positioned above an approximately three-metre drop.

The court later heard that the door had never been subject to an adequate risk assessment. Even more significantly, staff had reportedly identified it as a potential safety problem more than a month before the accident. This meant the hazard was not simply unforeseeable. People working within the venue had already recognised that something could go wrong.

A catastrophic outcome

Presdee suffered devastating spinal injuries and spent approximately six months in hospital. She was left paraplegic and became a wheelchair user. Her injuries meant that she could no longer continue the theatre career she had built. Her previous credits had included productions such as The History Boys at the National Theatre and Jerusalem at the Royal Court. She subsequently returned to her native Australia.

The consequences therefore extended far beyond the immediate accident. They included permanent disability, extensive medical treatment and rehabilitation, the need for ongoing care and adapted accommodation, loss of future earnings and the end of her established career in theatre.

The prosecution

Following an investigation, Westminster City Council prosecuted Soho Theatre Company. The company admitted health and safety breaches. The court heard that there should have been a system for identifying and controlling the danger presented by the doorway.

The case was particularly significant because the necessary controls were neither complicated 
nor expensive. The prosecution argued that, at the most basic level, the door could simply have been secured and appropriately signed. When the case reached Southwark Crown Court in December 2014, Soho Theatre Company was fined £20,000 and ordered to pay £10,000 in costs.

The judge described the risk presented by the doorway as obvious and known, noting that it had increased over time.

£3.7 million compensation

Separate from the criminal prosecution, Presdee pursued a civil compensation claim. An out-of-court settlement of £3.7 million was agreed with insurers for Soho Theatre and Headlong Theatre.

At the time, Equity described it as the largest compensation settlement in the union’s history and it was believed to be one of the largest settlements of its type within the UK entertainment industry.

The size of the settlement demonstrates the potentially enormous financial consequences of a serious workplace accident. Compensation following catastrophic injury may have to account not simply for the initial injury, but for decades of care, adapted accommodation and equipment, loss of earnings and other future needs.

What could have prevented the accident?

What makes this case particularly useful when studying risk assessment is the simplicity of the controls that could have prevented an extremely serious accident. A suitable assessment should have identified:

Hazard: An elevated doorway opening directly onto a substantial drop. 

Who could be harmed:
Theatre employees, visiting production staff, contractors, performers and 
potentially anyone else accessing the backstage area.

Potential consequence:
A fall of approximately three metres resulting in major injury, permanent disability or potentially death.

A hierarchy of controls could then have considered whether access through the doorway was necessary and, when it was not required, how access could be physically prevented. Possible controls could have included locking or securing the door, installing a physical barrier or guard, controlling who had access to the area, providing suitable warning signage and ensuring adequate backstage/work lighting. Indeed, evidence reported from the court proceedings indicated that fitting a padlock would have been a very straightforward task.

The key lesson: identifying a hazard isn’t enough

Perhaps the most important lesson from the Soho Theatre accident is the difference between recognising a hazard and managing it. The danger associated with the doorway had reportedly been identified before Presdee’s accident. But recognising that something is dangerous does not
protect anyone.

The process has to continue:
Identify the hazard - assess the risk - decide controls - implement controls - communicate them -
check that they remain effective.

Had that process been completed, something as simple as a locked door or effective physical barrier could have prevented a life-changing accident. The case also demonstrates why backstage and production areas deserve the same systematic approach to risk assessment as public areas. Theatre environments can contain unusual hazards: elevated scenery doors, stage edges, orchestra pits, temporary stairs, flying systems, technical equipment, changes in lighting and constantly changing configurations.

People unfamiliar with the venue are particularly vulnerable because they may reasonably interpret an ordinary-looking door, corridor or staircase as safe.

Reflection for learners

Consider the Soho Theatre case from the perspective of a venue manager completing a risk assessment.

If you discovered a door opening onto a three-metre drop:

1. How would you score the likelihood and potential consequence before additional controls
were introduced?

2. What immediate action would you take rather than waiting for the risk assessment
paperwork to be completed?

3. Would warning signage alone be sufficient, or should the hazard be physically prevented?

4. How would you ensure visiting companies, contractors and temporary workers were aware
of unusual backstage hazards?

5. What system would you use to make sure hazards reported by staff were actually actioned
and closed out?

The central message is straightforward:

A risk assessment has no value if an identified hazard is allowed to remain uncontrolled. In this case, a relatively simple and inexpensive control could have prevented a worker suffering permanent, life-changing injuries.

Sources

The Guardian – “Stage manager is awarded £3.7m compensation after being left paralysed”
Provides details of the accident, the previous identification of the doorway as a safety risk, Presdee’s injuries and the compensation settlement.

London Evening Standard – “Theatre pays out £3.7m after stage manager was left paralysed”
Reports the court proceedings, absence of a risk assessment, earlier concerns about the door, the £20,000 fine and £10,000 costs.
Morrish Solicitors – Rachael Presdee case
The solicitors who represented Presdee provide details of the accident, injuries, civil settlement and separate criminal prosecution.
Equity – Annual Report 2015
Equity’s annual report records its support for Presdee and the £3.7 million damages award following the accident. (equity.org.uk)
Created with