Next IOSH Working Safely in Events: 26 November!

CASE STUDY

Canal Trust: When Volunteering Becomes Dangerous

You're not signed in yet

Sign up for a free account to read this case study and download the full PDF.
In August 2016, Peter Konitzer was volunteering with the Wilts & Berks Canal Trust, helping with restoration work at Pewsham Locks in Wiltshire. The project had moved well beyond routine volunteering activities such as gardening, clearing vegetation and removing rubbish. Volunteers were now undertaking construction work.

Peter was working inside an excavation, removing temporary props supporting a retaining wall, when part of the wall collapsed. He was trapped and suffered fatal crushing injuries.

What went wrong?

The subsequent investigations revealed serious failures in the way the work had been planned and managed. The temporary propping was inadequate, and there was no clear safe method for installing or removing the props. More significantly, the 2025 coroner’s report concluded that the project involved elements
of heavy construction that were beyond the experience and capabilities of the volunteer workforce. The coroner identified failures including:

• inadequate understanding of legal responsibilities;
• insufficient appreciation of relevant construction standards and guidance;
• failure to obtain appropriate temporary works designs;
• inadequate risk assessments and method statements; and
• inadequate planning before construction work began.

Evidence presented at the inquest also indicated that volunteers were undertaking work for which they were not sufficiently competent, without competent supervision or adequate task-specific risk assessments and written working methods.

The consequences

The Wilts & Berks Canal Trust pleaded guilty to breaching Section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974. In June 2024, the Trust was: fined £30,000 and ordered to pay £10,822 in costs. The following year, an inquest examined the circumstances surrounding Peter’s death. On 21 March 2025, the jury concluded that Peter had been unlawfully killed. 

What can charities learn from this?

This case demonstrates an important principle: Being a volunteer does not make an activity low risk. Charities often rely on people who are willing to help wherever they are needed. But enthusiasm and willingness are not substitutes for competence, training or professional expertise. This becomes particularly important when volunteers move from relatively straightforward activities into higher-risk work. For a charity event, consider volunteers who are asked to help with:

• temporary structures
• vehicle movements
• electrical equipment
• heavy lifting
• work at height
• barriers
• staging
• event build and breakdown

The question should never simply be: “Is someone willing to do it?” It should be: “Are they competent to do it safely, have we properly assessed the risk, and should a volunteer be doing this task at all?” Think about your events and activities Consider the volunteers involved in one of your charity events. 

Are any volunteers undertaking activities that require greater competence, training or supervision than their role might initially suggest?
Are there any tasks that should actually be carried out by a competent employee, specialist or 
contractor instead?

Sources

Courts and Tribunals Judiciary (2025), Peter Konitzer: Prevention of Future Deaths Report. 
This is the primary source for the inquest findings and coroner’s concerns.
The Construction Index (2024), Canal trust fined following death of volunteer.
Provides details of the prosecution, investigation findings, fine and costs.
2 Hare Court (2025), Jury Returns Conclusion of Unlawful Killing in Health & Safety Inquest.
Provides further detail about the evidence presented during the two-week inquest.
Volunteer, 63, dies after canal lock wall collapses.

Created with