Next IOSH Working Safely in Events: 26 November!

CASE STUDY

Brighton Marathon: A Fatal Medical Emergency

You're not signed in yet

Sign up for a free account to read this case study and download the full PDF.

The fundraising challenge

On 14 April 2013, 23-year-old Sam Harper Brighouse took part in the Brighton Marathon. Sam, a biology graduate from Forest Hill in south-east London, was running the 26.2-mile event to raise money for Arms Around The Child, a charity supporting vulnerable children, including children affected by HIV/AIDS.

His original fundraising target was relatively modest: £500. Like thousands of charity fundraisers every year, Sam had chosen a physically demanding
challenge as a way of supporting a cause he cared about.
He appeared an unlikely candidate for a serious medical emergency. He was described as fit and healthy, had prepared for the marathon and had not undertaken the event recklessly. Although he had asthma, the subsequent inquest found that this did not contribute to his death. But approximately 16 miles into the race, something went catastrophically wrong.

What happened?

At around the 16-mile point, Sam became seriously unwell and collapsed on Grand Avenue in Hove. Emergency services were called at approximately 11:45am. Medical staff, including doctors and paramedics, together with an off-duty police officer, treated him at the scene.
Initial indications suggested that he had suffered a cardiac arrest.

Attempts were made to resuscitate him before he was transported to the Royal Sussex County Hospital. He subsequently died. The Brighton Marathon had around 9,315 competitors taking part that year. Initially, Sam’s death appeared to be another tragic example of sudden cardiac arrest during endurance sport. The subsequent inquest, however, revealed a considerably more complicated sequence of events.

What caused Sam’s death?

The inquest heard that Sam had suffered from bowel ischaemia – a condition in which the blood supply to the bowel becomes severely restricted. Consultant pathologist Dr Mark Taylor explained that gastrointestinal symptoms are relatively common among marathon runners.
At the severe end of the spectrum, endurance exercise can be associated with ischaemic bowel conditions. (The Guardian)

In Sam’s case, the condition became catastrophic. The coroner ultimately determined that he died from bowel ischaemia and gastrointestinal haemorrhage. However, there was not one simple cause. The inquest concluded that his death resulted from an unusual combination of factors associated
with endurance exercise, including:

• hyperthermia;
• dehydration;
• prolonged physical exertion;
• hyperosmolar sports supplements; and
• the use of ibuprofen.

Sam had reportedly taken two or four ibuprofen tablets during the race, alongside sports supplements. The coroner described the combination of circumstances as effectively a “perfect storm”. His potassium level had risen to around three times its normal level, which caused his heart to
stop. Importantly, this was not a case of an inexperienced participant recklessly undertaking a challenge for which he had made no preparation. The coroner specifically concluded that Sam had prepared sensibly for the marathon. The products he had used were recognised products, and his behaviour was not considered reckless.

The formal verdict was misadventure.

An extraordinarily rare event

The medical circumstances were extremely unusual.The coroner described the case as “extraordinarily rare”, and evidence suggested that the precise combination of factors leading to Sam’s death may not previously have been recorded.

This is important when considering the case from a risk-management perspective. Risk assessment does not mean predicting every possible freak occurrence.
Instead, organisers and charities need to identify reasonably foreseeable categories of harm and implement proportionate controls. An organiser could not reasonably have been expected to predict Sam’s exact medical reaction. However, the broader hazards associated with endurance
events are foreseeable: physical exhaustion, dehydration, hyperthermia, gastrointestinal illness, collapse and medical emergencies.
The case therefore demonstrates the difference between predicting an exact accident and recognising a broader category of risk.

Could Sam have recognised what was happening?

Another difficulty highlighted by the inquest was the challenge participants face in distinguishing ordinary discomfort from symptoms indicating something much more serious. Running a marathon hurts. Participants expect fatigue, aching muscles, stomach discomfort, thirst and general physical distress. Evidence at the inquest suggested that Sam may not have recognised the significance of his symptoms because he could reasonably have interpreted abdominal discomfort as simply being associated with running a marathon. That creates an important issue for charity challenge events.

Participants need to understand that determination is not always desirable. Messages such as:

“Keep going.”
“Don’t give up.”
“Do it for the charity.”

can be highly motivating. But they can become problematic if they contribute to someone ignoring
symptoms that should cause them to stop and seek medical assistance.

Problems locating the casualty

The case also exposed a completely different event-management issue: emergency responders need to be able to locate casualties quickly. A senior member of the South East Coast Ambulance Service who responded to the incident described difficulty finding Sam among the crowds. He reportedly ran approximately 450–500 metres carrying medical equipment, asking marshals where the incident was. Some were unable to tell him exactly where the casualty was. Eventually, people further along the route were seen waving to indicate Sam’s location. The responder explained that the delay amounted to only minutes, but also made the important point that minutes can be critical during a cardiac emergency. In Sam’s particular case, however, the evidence was that this delay did not cause his death. His underlying condition had progressed to the point where it was considered unrevivable.

T
hat distinction matters. The lesson should not be:
“Sam died because the ambulance team couldn’t find him.”

The evidence does not support that conclusion. Instead, the incident identified a weakness that could have been critical in a different emergency.

The importance of location information

The responder suggested that more frequent location markers around the marathon route could have helped emergency teams identify incidents more quickly.
At the time, markers were positioned primarily at mile intervals. This raises an important question for anyone organising a charity walk, run, cycle ride or similar event:
If somebody calls for help, can they tell you exactly where they are?
Consider a charity walk covering 20 miles of countryside. A participant telephones the event control number and says:

“Someone has collapsed. We need an ambulance.”

The obvious next question is: “Where are you?”

If the answer is: “I’m not sure. Somewhere between checkpoint two and checkpoint three…”, valuable time may be lost. Location systems therefore form an important part of emergency planning. Controls could include:

• numbered route markers;
• kilometre or mile references;
• identifiable checkpoints;
• what3words or GPS locations;
• clearly numbered marshal positions;
• route maps available to event control;
• accurate incident reporting procedures;
• radios or other communications for marshals; and
• predetermined emergency access points.

Medical provision was not necessarily at fault

It is also important that this case is not presented as evidence that the Brighton Marathon simply failed to provide appropriate medical assistance.

The inquest heard positive evidence about the treatment Sam received. The ambulance representative described the medical care provided as being of a high standard, while the organisers subsequently stated that Sam had received immediate expert assistance from the event’s medical team. The medical evidence indicated that once Sam collapsed, his condition was irreversible.

The case therefore demonstrates another important principle: Good emergency planning cannot guarantee that every casualty will survive. Risk management aims to reduce risk so far as reasonably practicable. It cannot eliminate every possibility of serious illness or death, particularly when thousands of individuals with different physiological characteristics are undertaking demanding physical activity.

What does this mean for charities?

A charity may not organise the marathon itself. It might simply:

• purchase charity places;
• recruit runners;
• provide fundraising packs;
• set fundraising targets;
• provide branded running vests;
• promote participants through social media;
• organise cheer points; and
• celebrate successful finishers.

The event organiser will normally retain responsibility for managing the marathon itself. However, the charity should still consider what it communicates to its fundraisers. For example:

• Does the fundraising pack contain appropriate health and safety information?
• Are participants directed towards the organiser’s medical guidance?
• Are they encouraged to train appropriately?
• Are they advised not to participate when ill or injured?
• Are they told to seek appropriate medical advice where necessary?
• Are they warned about unfamiliar supplements or medication during endurance exercise?
• Most importantly, are participants explicitly told that it is acceptable to stop?

A fundraiser should never believe that raising £500, £1,000 or £10,000 for a charity means they have an obligation to finish an event regardless of their physical condition.

Sports supplements and medication

Sam’s case also raises a less obvious hazard associated with charity endurance events. Participants may use:

• energy gels;
• electrolyte products;
• sports drinks;
• caffeine products;
• painkillers; and
• other supplements.

They may regard these as normal components of endurance sport. Sam’s family subsequently highlighted this issue themselves, urging people taking part in
endurance events to recognise that supplements and analgesics can carry risks.

For charities, the sensible approach is generally not to provide medical advice outside their competence. Instead, participants can be directed towards authoritative event, sporting and medical guidance and encouraged to seek professional advice where necessary.

The risk-assessment lesson

Sam Harper Brighouse’s death is a particularly powerful case study because there was no obvious reckless act.

He was young.
He was considered fit.
He had trained.
He was raising money for charity.
He used recognised sports products.
He had no reason to expect that completing the marathon would result in his death.

Yet a combination of physical exertion, dehydration, heat, supplements and medication contributed to an extraordinarily rare and ultimately fatal medical condition. (The Guardian)

That is why risk assessment must consider people as well as physical hazards. When assessing a charity sporting challenge, it is not enough to identify: traffic, slippery surfaces, crowding and trip hazards. The assessment should also consider: participant health, physical exertion, fatigue,
weather, hydration, medication and supplements, medical provision, emergency communications and emergency access.

Key learning point

Charity challenges deliberately encourage people to push themselves. That is often part of their appeal. Someone might run their first marathon, climb a mountain, cycle hundreds of miles or complete an obstacle course specifically because they want to raise money for a cause that matters to them.

But fundraising motivation can never override participant welfare. The Sam Harper Brighouse case demonstrates that even a young, apparently healthy and appropriately prepared participant can experience a catastrophic medical emergency. Charities and event organisers cannot remove that possibility completely.

What they can do is provide clear information, encourage appropriate preparation, avoid creating pressure to continue when someone is unwell, provide effective medical arrangements and ensure that emergency responders can rapidly locate and reach a casualty. The fundamental message for anyone managing a charity challenge is therefore:

Completing the challenge is never more important than the participant’s health.

Questions for learners

1. What hazards can you identify from Sam’s case beyond the obvious physical hazards associated with a marathon?

2. What information should a charity provide to supporters who sign up to undertake a marathon on its behalf?

3. How could an organiser improve the ability of medical teams to locate casualties quickly along a long event route?

4. How might the motivational language used in charity fundraising unintentionally encourage participants to continue when they should stop?

5. Where should the boundary lie between providing sensible safety information and giving participants medical advice?

6. If the charity is not organising the marathon itself, what risks should it still consider when recruiting and supporting its fundraisers?

Sources

The Guardian – Brighton marathon runner died from bowel failure (28 August 2013)
Detailed reporting from the inquest covering Sam’s collapse, bowel ischaemia, the medical evidence and difficulties encountered by emergency responders in locating him.
The Guardian – Brighton Marathon runner died after reaction to ibuprofen and supplements (30 August 2013)
Reports the coroner’s final findings, including the combination of endurance exertion, dehydration,
hyperthermia, supplements and ibuprofen and the verdict of misadventure.
ITV News – Pledges flood in for dead runner
Contemporary coverage of Sam’s collapse, the Brighton Marathon, his fundraising for Arms
Around The Child and the substantial increase in donations following his death.
The Independent – ‘Extraordinarily rare and unusual’ bowel disorder killed marathon man
Further reporting from the inquest, including evidence concerning the medical condition and the difficulties experienced by ambulance personnel locating Sam through the crowds.
Read The Independent’s report

Serjeants’ Inn Chambers – Inquest into death of Brighton Marathon runner
Professional legal summary confirming the coroner’s findings of bowel ischaemia, gastrointestinal haemorrhage and the contributing factors of endurance exercise, hyperthermia, dehydration, NSAIDs and hyperosmolar sports supplements.
Arms Around The Child – JustGiving
The charity’s fundraising page records Sam Harper Brighouse’s fundraiser and the continuing legacy of the donations made in his name.
Londoner who died on marathon ‘was as fit as a fiddle’ say his family

Created with